I got back from New Hampshire on Sunday night and was feeling a little restless. Originally B and I were going to finally go see Watchmen. I read the graphic novel in college in my Violence in American Culture class and while comic books aren't my thing, I fell in love with the novel. I got the book for B for Hanukkah but it seemed to take him forever to read it. Anyway, the movie is now only playing at the Davis Square movie theater and by the time we got home from New Hampshire, there was no time to make it over there.
So I was a little bummed, especially since I was antsy to do something. For my birthday, B's lovely friends (and mine too now) S and O got me a gift card to
Craigie on Main. They had gone one night and thought that we would really enjoy going. After I got the giftcard, I did some research and found that they do a Chef's Whim after 9 PM on Sundays (although they now offer it on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday - I guess the economy is hitting everyone and they want to drum up some business). Since S and O live around the corner from Craigie on Main, we called them around 8 to see if they'd be up for a late dinner. They were free and we made a 9:30 reservation.
B and I made a quick change of clothes and I finally got to rock the
leaf headband B bought me. We were at Urban Outfitters a few more months ago and I was admiring it, but didn't want to splurge (I know, this is a rare moment financial conservativism for me). So he bought one in black for me. I brought it with me to Vegas but totally forgot to wear it. But I was happy to throw it on for an improptu dinner double date!
We jumped on the Red Line to Central Square. I was unfamiliar with where it was located, but happy to find that it was only a few minutes walk from the T stop. We got there a little early and headed to the bar. B had a Northern Lights - a cocktail with St. Germain (yummy elderflower liquor), scotch, lime and bitters. I tried to order my standard dirty Ketel martini (extra dirty) but was shocked to discover that they didn't served Ketel One. Maybe this is what happens when you cross the river? I chose their Rain vodka instead and it was a big mistake. Organic vodka does not a good martini make. S and O arrived shortly and we headed over to our table.
We started out with the standard bread basket. B and I chose the "surprise" (i.e. non-vegetarian) six-course tasting and S and O chose the vegetarian tasting. Our server also gave us cards to write down what we liked as we went through each course.
Our first course was a bite of sable fish with caviar and tiny potato chips. It was a fresh and delightful way to start the meal.
Our second course was a salad consisting of hirmasa sashimi, sugar white beets, oroblanco salsa, avocado, whitefish roe, and pine nut puree. This was again delightful and the acidic touch to this course was perfect.
Our third course was more substantial with a charred black cod served on top of red onions and bitter lemon. The cod was incredibly delicious. While I was surprised that the first three courses were all fish courses but each fish was cooked differently. This seemed more of a New England hearty fish dish and I was very satisfied, especially the contrast with the bitter lemon.
The fourth dish was probably my least favorite - a poached egg served with spring vegetables (cooked asparagus, radishes, celery, micro greens, sweet pea coulis) and a scattering of snails. This was cooked a la Schmaltz (i.e. in chicken fat) and served with chicken cracklings. Our server encouraged us to crack the egg yolk and to mix it with the spring vegetables. While everything was cooked properly, it was just not, how do I put it, a pretty dish. The burgundy snails were also chopped up pretty thinly so it was also difficult to get a good taste of the snails. It was just a shame because I'm a huge fan of all of the ingredients but the sloppy presentation just ruined the dish.
Our final savory course was a skirt steak cooked medium rare. The skirt steak was served with marrow, beef tongue, foie gras on top a bed of red rice, mustard grains and greens. I don't know how to describe this dish, except that it was delicious in every bite. I thought it was really interesting how the different parts of beef were served with each other and created a delicious contrast in texture. I'm not sure if this dish is served on their regular menu but I would definitely order it again.
Before we hit our dessert course, we were served with bites of sorbet to cleanse our palate. Each of us had a different sorbet - blood orange, pear, Myer lemon, and grapefruit - served with candied kumquat. We did a little swapping around and I was happy to end up with the blood orange. It was definitely what I needed to get ready for the dessert course.
Again, we were all served a different dessert. I happily ended up with a unique dish - dessert grits. Our dessert server explained that it was a warm sweet white corn grits served with hazelnuts, dried fruit compote, demerara brulee and topped with canela ice cream. It felt almost like a deconstructed fruit crisp and the hazlenuts added a perfect touch.
Just when we thought we were done with our desserts, we had one final touch of a small cup of hot cocoa spiced with ancho chile and cardamon. No one at our table could really finish the cocoa because it was both so rich and we were so full.
The meal was overall delicious. I was a little disappointed that there were three fish courses. S really didn't like one of her courses - a haroseth-stuffed sweet vidalia onion. While she ate the spring vegetables and carrot jus served with the stuffed onion, she really didn't like the onion at all. The server asked if everything was okay and she politely said that it just wasn't her course. At the end of the meal, while we were nibbling on our lemon madelines, the server came back and said that they noticed that she didn't enjoy the course and gave her a $25.00 gift card for another visit. I thought it was a nice touch. I'd definitely go back, but probably to choose my own plates.
The Chef's Whim was a great way to end a lovely Sunday - good food and good company makes the world a better place.
On a sidenote, my friend A was telling me today how she thinks B and I are such a city couple because we are always out and about in the city. I was honestly so flattered by her calling us a cosmopolitan couple and have to give her a little shout-out.
xoxo